- Crisis Management
“We can’t take a side.”
“We can’t comment on everything.”
“The war is in the Middle East. This doesn’t impact us.”
Leadership has never been a sideline sport.
Yet it’s exactly those sentiments from CEOs and other senior leaders that led to silence and being completely tone-deaf inside organizations after the October 7 terrorist attacks. It’s especially striking after many CEOs have spoken out on so many other DEI&B-related issues before.
None of us can comprehend as humans why denouncing hate and discrimination in any form was so difficult after the horrific events in the Middle East. And why there was such a lack of concern and support for employees impacted by this conflict. CEOs have a responsibility to denounce hate and ensure they create a safe workplace for everyone.
They are complicit in their silence.
Have CEOs not read their own prescribed values or are they just words on colorful posters? Are their organizations not on some kind of a DEI&B journey to create better, more productive and inclusive work environments, or is that just lip-service to quell activists? Are they not able to empathize with those who are affected – Jews, Arabs, Muslims, and the employees who watched the horrors on social media and on television. Surely they should be able to show they care about their employees – in this case by denouncing hate – without having to go on “Undercover Boss” to get close to their frontline teams.
Plus, it’s not like organizations haven’t been used to commenting on issues that arise, and now many have playbooks and dedicated teams to help decide if, when, and how to comment.
Finally, if there’s no moral imperative to communicate, it’s clearly in the best self-interest of organizations. After all, when employees’ well-being is affected, we know that there’s a great possibility that work will be stopped, slowed, or interrupted. Discretionary effort disappears. Today more than ever, focus is critical to business success: accelerating results, delivering innovation, and driving strategy.
Yet our research conducted in partnership with The Harris Poll reveals the appalling job by most organizations in not communicating about this issue.
What we Learned
Among the key findings from the survey of 2,154 U.S. employees, which was conducted over two waves in late October and early November 2023:
Communicators Rate the Key Components of Successful Communication
The research also included a quantitative survey of 118 communication leaders to determine key components of best practice communications and a content analysis of 68 internal company statements.
Communicators identified 12 essential components of effective communication and rated concern, empathy, and authenticity as the most important.
However, when the actual internal statements were assessed for those top components, about 1/3 of the statements didn’t include concern and authenticity, two of the top elements.
That’s why organizations and leaders need to look at everything they say and do through a human lens – and craft communication with what matters most to employees using ACE (authenticity, concern, and empathy) as the foundation.
Key Takeaways and Next Steps for Communication Leaders
This research underscores an unfortunate reality in many organizations today: some companies think the best decision is to say nothing when issues arise. That decision has a significant potential adverse business impact and is a missed opportunity.
Across organizations of all sizes, the impact of either saying nothing or poor communication includes the potential for under-productivity, distraction, and business slowdown.
Among the best practices for communicators to adopt when major geopolitical or other issues emerge:
A Need for Reflection on the Part of CEOs and Senior Leaders
When my kids were younger, I would often offer them a re-do when they made what Steve and I might consider a large mistake. Sometimes that was spurred on by bouts of crying and apologizing; every time, it was the perfect coaching and learning opportunity.
There’s a need for significant reflection here on what we learned. Given the research results, and our own experience here, we know better now, so I hope we will do better.
Issues are not going away. Backlash and controversy will still be a reality today. Employee well-being will continue to be a hugely important challenge and opportunity inside organizations. As Adam Grant recently said, we’re in a permacrisis, or feeling of tremendous permanent uncertainty.
There’s a re-do opportunity coming up. We don’t know when it will be, but we know there’s another issue that’s going to challenge CEOs.
When that issue arises, I hope CEOs and senior leaders will lead with their hearts IN their heads and do the right thing. And help employees understand the reasons behind the decision – because silence isn’t the answer.
In the meantime, if their values are words on a page, better activate those current values or co-create new values that reflect who your organization really is. They help guide actions in defining moments.
If their DEI&B efforts are “lip service,” fix that and prove it with actions.
If their own biases got in the way, it’s time for coaching and more self-reflection.
Finally, if they’re not getting proper counsel on what to do when issues arise, get new counsel.
It’s often the moments that challenge us most where we learn the most.
This is one of those moments.
You can find more details on the study by The Harris Poll for The Grossman Group here.
The theme of uncertainty was central in the 2023 Page International Exchange in Brussels, and for go…