By Rachel Catanach, Global Chair of Corporate Affairs, FleishmanHillard and Leela Stake, Global Managing Director for Responsible Business

Only 10% of consumers say they have real trust in large organizations today, according to License to Lead research. This statistic frames one of the toughest challenges facing chief communications officers: how do you communicate progress and impact credibly when skepticism about corporate claims is at an all-time high?

That question was at the center of a roundtable discussion, "The Credibility Cliff: Reclaiming Your License to Lead in a Trust Crisis," convened recently by Page Society and FleishmanHillard in New York. The intimate, Chatham House Rule conversation brought together chief communications officers and sustainability and impact leaders to explore how organizations can authentically communicate change and positive impact. Stakeholders are scrutinizing more closely, and they are not judging organizations based on what they say they stand for, but on what they do when the pressure is on. 

Why the Say/Do Gap Matters Now

For communication leaders, the gap between how leaders and stakeholders see the situation is striking. Consider the numbers:

  • 49% of executives are very optimistic about corporate ability to address challenges; 20% of engaged consumers agree. 
  • 51% of executives have high confidence leaders act in society’s interest; 19% of engaged consumers agree.  
  • 44% of executives believe large companies are very prepared for disruption; 15% of engaged consumers agree. 

That perception gap is the say/do gap in practice. Closing it, and earning permission to act and adapt, has become one of the defining leadership challenges of today. While a large majority of engaged consumers say integrity and honesty are very important to them, only a small fraction believe leaders of major companies demonstrate those qualities often. That integrity gap isn't proof that companies are lying. It's a signal of just how high the bar for credibility has risen, and how much work is required to close the distance between stakeholder expectations and stakeholder perception.

The research also found stakeholders are willing to accept adaptation and evolving priorities if organizations explain their reasoning and what tradeoffs need to be made. What they won't forgive is the sense that values shift with convenience rather than conviction.

Themes From the Room

Several threads ran through the discussion:

  • The stakeholder landscape has shifted. Leaders risk overindexing on the loudest voices rather than the ones most material to their business. 
  • The messenger matters as much as the message. In an environment of low institutional trust, employees, local leaders and other credible voices may be better positioned than senior executives to reach certain audiences. 
  • Humility is not weakness. Acknowledging concerns and demonstrating a willingness to listen builds more credibility than defensiveness ever will. 
  • Cross-functional alignment is essential. Communications, sustainability, legal and public affairs must work together to determine what an organization should, and should not, say. 
  • Progress doesn't have to be finished to be credible. Work can be communicated authentically while it is still incomplete, and stakeholders may accept that priorities evolve. They will not accept reversals made without an explanation of what changed and why. 
  • Credibility is built through repeated moments of trust. Smaller, consistent demonstrations that an organization keeps its word can matter more than major commitments or one-off campaigns.

As one participant framed it, the goal isn't to eliminate all risk from communicating about impact. Instead, it's to determine what an acceptable level of tension looks like, and to move from reacting to scrutiny toward shaping the conversation before skepticism hardens into opposition.

An Open Question for CCOs

As you plan for 2027, how is your organization deciding what to say, what to hold back, and how to prove commitments are credible over time? 

Rachel Catanach is a Page Up member and leads global corporate affairs at FleishmanHillard.